Bengaluru: The Greater Bengaluru Authority’s (GBA) ambitious plans to expand the city’s road network could face significant implementation challenges due to the absence of a clear policy on land acquisition, compensation and voluntary land surrender. Although several kilometres of roads have been identified in the proposed road circulation maps, uncertainty over how the required land will be secured could prevent many of these projects from moving forward.
The issue has raised concerns among urban planners, property owners and infrastructure experts, who believe that identifying road alignments alone will not be sufficient to improve Bengaluru’s connectivity. A clear framework covering land acquisition, compensation, development rights and coordination between government agencies is essential to ensure that proposed roads are eventually constructed.
According to a reports, around 85% of similar roads identified in the 2007 Bengaluru Development Authority (BDA) Master Plan remain unbuilt. The situation has raised questions about whether the latest road proposals could face a similar fate if the government does not address the existing policy gaps.
Land acquisition and compensation emerge as major challenges
One of the biggest obstacles facing Bengaluru’s proposed road network is the lack of a straightforward mechanism for acquiring private land and compensating property owners.
Under the existing system, road widening generally takes place through two approaches. The civic authorities can issue a formal land acquisition notification and compensate property owners through Transferable Development Rights (TDR). Alternatively, landowners developing layouts or high-rise buildings may be required to surrender portions of their land for road widening as a condition for obtaining development approvals.
However, the voluntary land surrender mechanism largely depends on property owners undertaking development activities. When landowners do not initiate construction, the required land may remain unavailable for road projects.
The absence of a clear process allowing owners to voluntarily surrender land and receive compensation without waiting for a separate acquisition notification has become a significant concern.
As a result, several proposed roads could remain incomplete even after their alignments are identified in official planning documents.
Small landowners face greater difficulties
The proposed road plans could have a particularly significant impact on small property owners whose land falls within the identified road alignments.
Large landowners may have the financial capacity and sufficient land to benefit from additional development opportunities or Floor Space Index (FSI) benefits associated with surrendering land.
However, smaller property owners may not have enough land to make use of such benefits. If a substantial portion of a small plot is marked for a proposed road, the owner could face difficulties obtaining building approvals or developing the remaining property.
At the same time, without a formal acquisition notification or a clear voluntary surrender mechanism, the owner may not be able to claim compensation immediately.
The situation could leave some property owners unable to develop their land or receive compensation while waiting for the proposed road project to materialise.
A Hoodi resident, HM Chandrasheker, reportedly told Deccan Herald that his building plans had been rejected because his property was marked for a road under the Comprehensive Development Plan, despite several roads identified in the 2007 BDA Master Plan remaining unconstructed.
The issue has raised concerns about property rights, fairness and the need to protect the interests of smaller landowners while planning future infrastructure.
Hennur Road highlights the problem
The challenges associated with incomplete road development are visible on Hennur Road, also known as New Airport Road.
A six-lane carriageway narrows near the Sri Channakeshava Swamy Temple shortly after crossing the Outer Ring Road. The resulting bottleneck has continued for years, affecting traffic movement along the stretch.
The Greater Bengaluru Authority has yet to widen the affected section. Meanwhile, the adjoining properties have not undergone development that would require portions of the land to be surrendered for road expansion.
This situation illustrates how a road can remain incomplete when the authorities and property owners are unable to move forward with the land acquisition or surrender process.
Similar challenges have been reported along several peripheral roads, where rapid urbanisation has taken place without corresponding improvements in road infrastructure.
Temporary structures and shops along proposed road alignments can further complicate future development and contribute to congestion.
Sarjapur Road faces infrastructure deficit
The growing gap between urban expansion and road infrastructure is particularly evident along Sarjapur Road.
A study of the 17-kilometre stretch cited in the report highlighted the imbalance between Bengaluru’s built-up area and road availability.
The city has reportedly added nearly 150 square kilometres of built-up area every decade since 1990, while road infrastructure has not expanded at the same pace.
The study found significant differences in road availability across neighbourhoods.
- Sarjapur: Around 10 kilometres of road per square kilometre.
- Vijayanagar: Around 30 kilometres per square kilometre.
- Jayanagar: Around 23 kilometres per square kilometre.
- Whitefield, Dommasandra and Doddakannelli: Between 8 and 14.5 kilometres per square kilometre.
These figures highlight the uneven distribution of road infrastructure across the city.
Areas experiencing rapid residential and commercial development require better connectivity to accommodate increasing traffic volumes. Without adequate road networks, congestion and accessibility problems are likely to continue.
GBA identifies new road corridors
The Greater Bengaluru Authority has identified several kilometres of public and private land for proposed roads as part of its road circulation planning exercise.
The maps were published on October 12 under Section 12(1)(b) of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act, 1961. The draft proposals were opened for public objections and suggestions for a two-month period.
The objective is to identify and protect land required for future road development before further urbanisation makes construction more difficult.
However, identifying and reserving land for roads does not automatically mean that construction can begin. The authorities must still establish a clear process for acquiring the land, compensating affected owners and resolving legal and administrative issues.
Without these arrangements, several proposed road connections could remain restricted to planning documents rather than becoming functional roads.
Road planning also faces coordination concerns
Apart from land acquisition, differences in road design and planning standards across government agencies have raised additional concerns.
The road circulation plans prepared by the GBA, BDA and other agencies reportedly contain inconsistencies in proposed road widths and junction designs.
The Indian Roads Congress (IRC) prescribes standard road widths of 9, 12, 18 and 24 metres. However, the BDA’s road circulation map includes widths of 12.2, 18.3 and 25 metres.
The proposals also include roundabouts at certain locations where earlier plans had not identified such junctions.
Urban planning experts have questioned whether these designs were supported by adequate scientific assessments of traffic patterns and future transportation requirements.
They have also stressed the importance of integrating land-use planning with transportation infrastructure. Origin-destination studies, which examine where journeys begin and end, are considered important for understanding travel patterns and determining the requirements of a road network.
Another concern is that the road circulation map was published before the Directorate of Urban Land Transport (DULT) completed its report on Bengaluru’s Comprehensive Mobility Plan.
Experts believe that road development should be coordinated with the city’s broader mobility strategy rather than being undertaken through disconnected plans prepared by different agencies.
Government considers changes to TDR policy
Greater Bengaluru Development Minister Krishna Byre Gowda has indicated that the government is examining ways to make the Transferable Development Rights system more attractive to property owners.
He also stated that the government is insisting that local planning authorities allocate at least 50% of their revenue towards long-term infrastructure development, including roads, drinking water and sewage connections.
The government is also considering allowing landowners to voluntarily surrender portions of their properties for proposed roads without waiting for a separate land acquisition notification.
Urban planner Dhanya Thejas has suggested that TDR compensation in Bengaluru should be doubled, considering the higher land values in the city’s peripheral areas.
The planner also pointed to the policies followed in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, where mechanisms allow landowners to surrender land and seek compensation without waiting for a separate acquisition notification.
Such a framework could help address some of the difficulties faced by property owners and make road development more practical.
Clear policy needed to turn road plans into reality
Bengaluru’s road expansion plans highlight the need for a comprehensive approach to urban infrastructure development. While identifying future road corridors is an important step, the government must also establish clear rules covering land acquisition, compensation, voluntary surrender and development rights.
Equally important is coordination between the GBA, BDA and other planning agencies to ensure that road widths, junction designs and connectivity proposals follow consistent standards.
The proposed road network could help address the city’s growing infrastructure requirements. However, its success will depend on how effectively the government resolves the challenges surrounding land ownership, compensation and implementation.
Until a transparent and practical policy is introduced, Bengaluru risks adding more roads to its planning maps without ensuring that they become usable connections for residents.
