New Delhi: The recent correction in gold and silver prices has put exchange-traded fund (ETF) investors in India under pressure, prompting many to reconsider whether they should continue their systematic investment plans (SIPs), pause contributions or exit their investments.
After delivering substantial gains in recent months, both precious metals have witnessed a sharp reversal. The decline has affected gold and silver ETFs, leaving investors who entered at higher prices facing short-term losses.
However, a fall in prices does not automatically mean that investors should stop their SIPs. Financial experts suggest that the decision should depend on an individual’s investment horizon, financial goals, risk tolerance and existing allocation to precious metals rather than daily price movements.
The central question is whether the original reason for investing in gold and silver remains valid. Investors using these metals to diversify their portfolios may have different considerations from those who bought ETF units primarily to benefit from short-term price increases.
Why are gold and silver ETFs falling?
Gold and silver prices are influenced by several global factors, including interest-rate expectations, movements in the US dollar, bond yields, geopolitical developments and demand for safe-haven assets.
When markets expect interest rates to remain higher or rise further, non-yielding assets such as gold and silver can come under pressure. Higher bond yields increase the opportunity cost of holding precious metals, which do not generate interest or dividends.
Profit-booking after a prolonged rally can also accelerate a correction. Investors who accumulated metals at lower prices may sell part of their holdings to lock in gains, adding to downward pressure.
Silver can be particularly volatile because its price is influenced by both investment demand and industrial consumption. The metal is used in sectors such as electronics, solar energy and other industrial applications. Changes in expectations for industrial demand can therefore affect silver prices alongside broader financial-market movements.
Since gold and silver ETFs track the underlying commodities, movements in bullion prices generally influence their net asset values (NAVs). However, ETF market prices can also differ from NAVs depending on liquidity, demand and supply.
Should investors continue their SIPs?
For investors with a long-term investment horizon and an allocation that remains consistent with their financial plan, continuing existing SIPs may be a reasonable approach, according to experts cited in recent market coverage.
Regular investing spreads purchases across different price levels. When ETF prices decline, the same investment amount buys more units. If prices subsequently recover, the additional units accumulated at lower levels can help reduce the average purchase cost.
This approach is commonly known as rupee-cost averaging. It can reduce the need to predict the exact market bottom, although it does not guarantee profits or protect investors from further declines.
Nirpendra Yadav, senior research analyst at Bonanza Portfolio, has advised investors with longer investment horizons to continue their SIPs during corrections rather than attempting to time the market.
He also cautioned against increasing contributions aggressively simply because prices have fallen, particularly in silver, which tends to experience greater volatility.
The key condition is that the original investment objective and desired asset allocation should remain unchanged. Investors who bought gold or silver as part of a diversified portfolio should review whether that purpose still applies.
When should investors consider pausing their SIPs?
A temporary pause may be appropriate when an investor’s financial circumstances have changed.
For instance, a reduction in income, an unexpected expense or the need to preserve cash for an immediate financial commitment may justify reviewing monthly investments. Continuing an SIP should not come at the cost of essential expenses, emergency savings or repayment of high-cost debt.
Another reason to reconsider contributions is an excessive allocation to precious metals.
If gold and silver have increased substantially as a proportion of an investor’s portfolio during an earlier rally, their combined exposure may now be higher than originally intended. In such circumstances, continuing contributions at the same rate could increase concentration rather than improve diversification.
Investors may consider rebalancing their portfolios to bring the allocation back in line with their financial plan. This does not necessarily require selling all existing holdings or abandoning precious metals.
The decision should be based on the overall portfolio rather than the recent performance of one asset class.
Should investors stop investing or sell their ETF units?
A short-term decline alone may not be sufficient reason to exit gold and silver ETFs.
Selling during a correction can turn a temporary decline in market value into a realised loss. Investors who exit may also miss a subsequent recovery, although there is no guarantee that prices will rebound quickly or return to previous highs.
At the same time, holding precious metals indefinitely without reviewing their role in a portfolio is not necessarily a sound strategy.
Gold and silver do not provide regular income in the way that interest-bearing deposits or dividend-paying investments may. Their returns depend primarily on changes in market prices. They can also remain under pressure for extended periods.
Investors should therefore distinguish between a temporary market correction and a change in their own financial requirements. Those who need money in the near term may have different priorities from investors who can remain invested for several years.
Gold and silver require different risk considerations
Although both metals are commonly used to diversify portfolios, their price behaviour is not identical.
Gold is generally viewed as a store of value and a potential hedge during periods of economic or geopolitical uncertainty. Silver also has a monetary and investment role, but its industrial applications can make its price more sensitive to changes in manufacturing demand and economic activity.
NS Ramaswamy, head of the commodity desk and CRM at Ventura, has recommended maintaining a greater allocation to gold than silver within the precious-metal portion of a portfolio. His suggested split is 70:30 between gold and silver, with combined exposure of around 15% of the overall portfolio.
This is an expert’s suggested allocation, not a universal rule. The appropriate proportion will vary according to an investor’s financial goals, existing investments and ability to withstand volatility.
Investors should also remember that silver’s sharper price movements can make it unsuitable for those who are uncomfortable with substantial short-term fluctuations.
SIPs or lump-sum investments during the correction?
Investors with additional money to deploy may be tempted to make a large one-time purchase after a significant price fall. However, prices can decline further, making it difficult to identify the bottom.
Yadav has favoured staggered investments rather than deploying the entire available amount at once. Dividing the money into smaller instalments can spread the entry points and reduce dependence on a single market level.
Ramaswamy, meanwhile, has said investors with a longer horizon may consider lump-sum investments when signs of a recovery begin to emerge.
Both approaches involve market risk. A staggered strategy does not guarantee a better return, while waiting for a recovery may mean missing some of the initial rise in prices.
Before adding money, investors should assess their existing exposure to gold and silver, the proportion of precious metals in their overall portfolio, and their ability to remain invested through further volatility.
What should investors monitor next?
The direction of precious-metal prices will continue to depend on global economic and financial conditions. Investors may watch movements in US interest-rate expectations, bond yields and the dollar, along with central-bank purchases, ETF flows and geopolitical developments.
The Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI) data reported by News Karnataka showed that gold ETFs attracted net inflows of Rs 3,474.03 crore in October 2026, down nearly 22% from September. Silver ETFs, in contrast, received Rs 3,092.22 crore, an increase of more than 56% month-on-month.
These figures indicate that investor interest in precious-metal funds continued even as prices came under pressure. However, monthly inflows alone do not establish the future direction of bullion prices.
Investors should also examine ETF-specific factors such as expense ratios, tracking differences and liquidity. An ETF’s market price may not always match its underlying NAV, particularly when trading conditions are volatile.
The decision should follow the investment plan
The recent fall in gold and silver ETFs has created uncertainty for investors, but it does not make stopping every SIP the right response. Those with long-term goals and a suitable allocation may consider continuing their existing contributions, while people facing financial pressure or holding an excessive amount of precious metals may need to review or pause their plans.
The important distinction is between changing an investment strategy because personal circumstances have changed and reacting to short-term market movements. A disciplined approach, periodic portfolio reviews and an understanding of the risks associated with each metal can help investors make decisions without allowing market panic to dictate their financial plans.
