An examination malpractice case at the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay has drawn attention after a student caught using a smartphone and smartwatch during a test was allowed to complete the examination before disciplinary action was taken.
The incident was recounted by IIT Bombay professor Milind Tambe, who described the approach as an example of handling academic misconduct while also protecting a student’s dignity and privacy.
Student allowed to complete the test
According to Tambe, the student was caught using electronic devices during an examination. Instead of immediately removing the student from the examination hall, the invigilator allowed the test to continue.
The student was later spoken to privately, rather than being publicly confronted in front of classmates. The devices involved reportedly included a smartphone and smartwatch. Times of India report
Privacy considered alongside discipline
The case was subsequently referred for disciplinary proceedings. Rather than awarding a complete zero for the examination, the student reportedly received partial zero marks as part of the action taken.
Tambe said the handling of the incident reflected an effort to balance academic integrity with the student’s privacy and dignity. The approach also avoided turning the incident into a public spectacle.
The case has sparked discussion about how educational institutions can respond to examination malpractice while ensuring that disciplinary measures remain proportionate and respectful.
Academic institutions typically maintain strict rules against unauthorised electronic devices during examinations. At the same time, the incident highlights the different ways institutions may approach misconduct, particularly when disciplinary action is combined with opportunities for students to learn from their mistakes.