Mysuru: Advocate K.B. Natesh, who represents M.R. Rajesh in the Pandavapura presumed murder case, has alleged that police personnel tortured his client, administered electric shocks and forced him to sign documents to obtain a confession in a murder case involving a woman who has now been found alive.

Natesh said Rajesh had repeatedly maintained that he was innocent, but his claims were initially not taken seriously. The allegations have emerged after N. Manju, who went missing from Pandavapura in 2019 and was presumed murdered, was traced alive in Nagamangala taluk.

Rajesh was arrested over a phone call

Rajesh, a 33-year-old daily-wage labourer from Ragimuddanahalli, was arrested on August 12, 2021, in connection with Manju’s disappearance. The police investigation reportedly focused on the fact that Manju had used his mobile phone to call her family on the day she went missing.

According to Natesh, Rajesh had only lent his phone to Manju when she approached him at the Pandavapura bus stand seeking help to contact her family. However, the phone call reportedly became a key basis for the police action against him.

The police claimed to have recorded a confession statement in which Rajesh allegedly admitted to killing Manju. A chargesheet was subsequently filed against him for murder and destruction of evidence, even though Manju’s body had not been recovered.

Rajesh consistently denied involvement in the alleged crime. He spent around two-and-a-half years in prison before securing bail from the Karnataka High Court in February 2024. He continues to fight the case to clear his name.

Advocate alleges electric shocks and forced signatures

Natesh told the newspaper that Rajesh had informed him about the alleged treatment he faced in police custody.

According to the advocate, Rajesh claimed that police personnel tortured him, administered electric shocks and forced him to sign documents prepared by the investigators. Natesh said his client had maintained that he had not committed the murder, but the allegations were initially difficult for him to accept.

The advocate said he later secured bail for Rajesh from the High Court. The allegations of custodial torture and the circumstances surrounding the alleged confession have now become significant issues in the case.

These claims are allegations made by Rajesh through his advocate and will require an independent investigation to establish their veracity.

Woman’s return changes the course of the case

The case took an unexpected turn when Manju, who had been missing since June 23, 2019, was traced alive in Mayagondanahalli in Nagamangala taluk.

Manju reportedly told the police that she had eloped with Nagendra, a man from Chamarajanagar, and later married him. She said she had lived with him in Tamil Nadu before the couple settled in Mayagondanahalli. She also reportedly stated that she had no connection with Rajesh and was unaware that her father had accused him of murdering her.

Natesh said he was shocked after learning that Manju had visited her father’s house in Pandavapura and subsequently left. He travelled to Nagamangala, made enquiries and, with the help of an autorickshaw driver, traced her to the house where she was staying.

He then contacted the Bindiganavile Police and handed Manju over to them.

Complaint lodged against Manju’s father and witnesses

Natesh also said a complaint had been lodged at the Pandavapura Police Station against Manju’s father, Nagaraju, who had accused Rajesh of murder, and the witnesses Ananthapadmanabha and Gurukumar.

The original murder complaint was filed by Nagaraju in August 2021, more than two years after Manju went missing. It alleged that Rajesh had pushed her into the Cauvery River near Paschimavahini in Srirangapatna.

The police had proceeded with the investigation and filed a chargesheet, naming Nagaraju and others as witnesses. However, Manju’s discovery alive has raised questions about the basis of the murder allegation and the evidence collected during the investigation.

Advocate seeks action against retired inspector

Natesh said he would also submit a complaint to the Mandya Superintendent of Police seeking action against the then Pandavapura Police Inspector Prabhakar, who had arrested Rajesh and filed the chargesheet. The inspector has since retired.

Mandya Superintendent of Police V.J. Shobha Rani has said that a Deputy Superintendent of Police-rank officer would conduct an inquiry into the alleged lapses in the investigation and submit a report to the court.

The inquiry is expected to examine how the case was handled, the evidence relied upon to arrest and charge Rajesh, and the allegations surrounding the confession. The findings could determine whether action is warranted against the officers involved.

The case has raised serious concerns about the investigation process, particularly the reliance on an alleged confession when the missing woman had not been found. The allegations of custodial torture also underline the need for an impartial examination of the circumstances in which the statement was recorded.