Mandya: A woman who was presumed murdered after disappearing from Pandavapura in 2019 has been found alive, bringing to light serious questions about the police investigation that led to a man spending two-and-a-half years in prison on charges of killing her.
N. Manju, who went missing on June 23, 2019, was traced recently in Mayagondanahalli in Nagamangala taluk. Her return has turned the murder case against M.R. Rajesh, a daily-wage labourer from Ragimuddanahalli, on its head. Rajesh had been accused of pushing Manju into the Cauvery River near Paschimavahini in Srirangapatna. However, Manju has now reportedly told the police that she had eloped with the man she loved and had no connection with Rajesh.
Manju went missing in June 2019
Manju, daughter of Nagaraju and a resident of Hirode Street in Pandavapura, went missing on the night of June 23, 2019. She had married her maternal uncle, N.C. Manjunath, of Neelanakoppalu village in Srirangapatna, in 2009. After falling ill, she had returned to her parents’ house before disappearing.
Her family approached the Pandavapura Police, and a missing-person complaint was registered on July 3, 2019.
The case took a different turn nearly two years later when Manju’s father, Nagaraju, lodged another complaint on August 11, 2021, alleging that Rajesh had murdered his daughter by pushing her into the Cauvery River at Paschimavahini.
According to the complaint, Nagaraju had been informed about the alleged incident by two local residents, Ananthapadmanabha and Gurukumar. He claimed that Rajesh and Manju were in a relationship and alleged that Rajesh had killed her because he feared she would create problems for his marriage to another woman. These were allegations made in the complaint and had not been established through the recovery of a body.
Lending a mobile phone led to Rajesh’s arrest
Rajesh came under suspicion because Manju had reportedly approached him at the Pandavapura bus stand on the day she went missing and asked to use his mobile phone to call her family.
The call made from his number became a key basis for the police investigation. On August 12, 2021, the then Pandavapura Police Inspector Prabhakar arrested Rajesh on charges of murder and destruction of evidence.
The police reportedly recorded a confession statement claiming that Rajesh had admitted to killing Manju. However, her body was never recovered. Investigators stated that the passage of time had made it difficult to locate the body.
A chargesheet was subsequently filed before the court, naming Nagaraju and the two residents who had allegedly informed him about the incident, along with others, as witnesses.
Rajesh maintained that he had merely lent his phone to a woman at the bus stand and had no involvement in her disappearance. His bail applications were rejected twice by the 3rd Additional District and Sessions Court in Srirangapatna. The Karnataka High Court granted him bail in February 2024, after which he was released following approximately two-and-a-half years in prison.
Advocate traces Manju to Nagamangala
The case took an unexpected turn when advocate K.B. Natesh, who represented Rajesh, received information that Manju had recently visited her father’s house in Pandavapura and left.
After making enquiries, Natesh travelled to Nagamangala and sought information about her whereabouts. An autorickshaw driver who had dropped Manju at Mayagondanahalli helped lead him to the house where she was staying.
Natesh then contacted the Bindiganavile Police and handed Manju over to them. He also arranged for Rajesh’s father, Ramesh, to lodge a complaint in connection with the case. The complaint was registered as a Non-Cognisable Report (NCR), according to the report.
The development prompted fresh questions about the original investigation and the evidence used to charge Rajesh with murder.
Manju says she eloped with her lover
During police questioning, Manju reportedly stated that she had married Manjunath against her wishes and was in love with Nagendra, a man from Chamarajanagar.
She said she had eloped with Nagendra and subsequently married him. The couple reportedly lived in Tamil Nadu for a year before moving to Mayagondanahalli in Nagamangala taluk.
Manju also reportedly told the police that she had no connection with Rajesh and was unaware that her father had lodged a murder complaint accusing him of killing her.
She has been placed at the Santhwana counselling centre run by the Department of Women and Child Development in Nagamangala. Reports also stated that she expressed her willingness to give a statement before the court.
DySP-level inquiry ordered into investigation
The woman’s return has raised serious questions about how a murder case was built when no body had been recovered.
Mandya Superintendent of Police V.J. Shobha Rani said a Deputy Superintendent of Police-rank officer would conduct an inquiry into the alleged lapses in the investigation and submit a report to the court.
The investigation had relied on the complaint filed by Manju’s father and the alleged confession statement recorded by the police. The circumstances surrounding Rajesh’s arrest, the manner in which the confession was obtained and the decision to file a chargesheet despite the absence of a recovered body are among the issues that have come under scrutiny.
Rajesh’s case has also drawn attention to the consequences of an investigation based on allegations and circumstantial evidence without establishing what happened to the missing person. The fresh inquiry is expected to examine the role of the officers involved and identify where the investigation went wrong.
Similar case reported in Karnataka
The incident has brought back memories of another case in which a man accused of murdering his wife was later acquitted after she was found alive in Madikeri.
In that case, K. Suresh of Basavanahalli in Kushalnagar taluk had been arrested in connection with the alleged murder of his wife, Mallige. She was later traced living with another man. Suresh was acquitted, and the court directed the Home Department to pay him ₹1 lakh in compensation and ordered disciplinary action against five police officers.
The latest case in Mandya has once again highlighted the importance of thorough investigation and verification of evidence before pursuing serious criminal charges.
