In recent weeks, AI-generated videos depicting life in different historical eras have gone viral on TikTok, offering viewers a unique “point of view” experience from the past. These videos, created by Dan from the UK and Hogne from Norway, allow users to imagine waking up in ancient Rome, during the Black Death, or on the Nile in ancient Egypt. The videos aim to bring history to life by showcasing sights, sounds, and daily struggles of past societies, offering a glimpse into the past like never before.
While these videos have captivated millions of viewers, including those fascinated by history, they have also raised concerns among historians. Some experts worry about the accuracy of these depictions and the potential for misinformation, especially with the widespread use of AI. Dr. Amy Boyington, a historian, describes the videos as “amateurish” and sensationalized, pointing out significant historical inaccuracies, such as anachronistic elements like modern items or technology appearing in medieval or ancient settings. In one of Hogne’s most-watched videos, which depicts life during the Black Death, features like large glazed windows and train tracks are historically impossible for the 1300s.
Hogne and Dan, while acknowledging the creative liberties taken in their videos, stress that they are not meant to be factual recreations but rather artistic interpretations to evoke the feeling of a historical time period. Dan emphasizes that his videos are designed to spark curiosity and encourage viewers to conduct their own research into history.
Despite these intentions, the concern remains that AI-generated content could blur the line between fact and fiction. Dr. Boyington worries about the potential for historical manipulation, especially when viewers may not recognize the content as fictional. She notes that students may inadvertently use such content in academic settings, mistakenly treating it as factual.
However, many historians see the value in these videos, particularly as a tool to inspire curiosity about history. Dr. Boyington notes that these videos can serve as a gateway into historical research, encouraging viewers to explore further. Professor Elizabeth Frood echoes this sentiment, saying that if done accurately, these videos can have immense educational benefits by raising awareness and interest in historical events.
Though the viral nature of these AI-generated videos has captured public attention, their lack of source transparency raises questions about their reliability as educational tools. The debate continues on whether AI-driven historical reconstructions can provide accurate and meaningful insights into the past or if they risk distorting history in the pursuit of engagement.
Read also: