Dana Marie, an American national residing in Bengaluru, has stirred controversy with her suggestion that Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) should contribute taxes to India to ease the financial strain on resident taxpayers. She argued that while NRIs shouldn’t be taxed equally, even a partial contribution could help Indians cope with what she called an “insane tax burden.”

In a post on Threads, Marie claimed that high taxation is pushing many Indians to move abroad. She suggested that if NRIs paid taxes to India, it would not only boost revenue but also reduce brain drain by encouraging skilled professionals to stay and invest in the country.

Her remarks, however, faced severe backlash. Many pointed out that NRIs already contribute through investments, property taxes, and remittances. One critic argued that income tax is meant for those who reside in a country and benefit from its infrastructure and services. Another warned that such a policy could permanently deter NRIs from returning to India.

Dubai-based professional Mitesh Aswani dismissed Marie’s argument, stating that NRIs already invest heavily in India and that such comments reflect ignorance about their economic contributions.

The debate continues, with strong opinions on both sides regarding NRIs’ financial obligations and India’s taxation policies.