BENGALURU: Recent data from the Karnataka law department highlights significant challenges faced by the state government in legal battles across various courts, including the high court, district courts, and lower courts. In 2023, the government lost 14,706 cases, winning only 1,222. This trend of losing the majority of cases has persisted for years, with similar results in 2021 when the government lost 10,698 cases and won just 2,687.
Concerns have been raised about the efficacy of public prosecutors appointed by the government. Allegations suggest they have failed to present cases effectively. However, officials from the Advocate General’s office argue that these numbers do not provide a complete picture. They point out that many cases involve petitioners approaching the court due to a lack of response from a government department, resulting in mandamus orders which should not necessarily be considered losses for the government.
A senior official noted that bail orders, granted for various reasons, should not always be viewed as adverse to the government. The official emphasized the need for a comprehensive analysis, noting that frivolous cases and lack of cooperation from government departments significantly impact case outcomes.
A public prosecutor, speaking anonymously, acknowledged that lack of cooperation from various government departments often leads to losing cases. Inadequate evidence and delays in responding to court orders were cited as key issues. Law Minister HK Patil addressed these concerns in the recent Assembly session, stating that deputy commissioners have been tasked with monthly reviews of public prosecutors’ performance.