Mumbai: Tata Trusts chairman Noel Tata has renewed his demand for the audio and video recordings of two key Tata Sons meetings, while questioning the participation of Venu Srinivasan in the decision-making process concerning N Chandrasekaran’s reappointment as chairman.

In a fresh letter sent on Friday, November 20, to Tata Sons company secretary Suprakash Mukhopadhyay, Noel sought the recordings of the September 17 board meeting and the September 3 meeting of the company’s Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC). He also reiterated that Srinivasan, a Tata Trusts nominee director on the Tata Sons board, should have recused himself from discussions and voting on Chandrasekaran’s reappointment because of an alleged conflict of interest.

The latest communication marks another escalation in the differences between Noel and sections of the Tata Sons board over corporate governance, disclosures and the process followed for Chandrasekaran’s continuation as executive chairman.

Tata Sons has previously rejected Noel’s request for the September 17 recordings and denied that the reported business relationship involving TVS Motor Company and Hanno One Warehousing created a conflict of interest. The company has maintained that the relevant disclosures were made and that the reappointment decision followed the applicable procedure.

Why Noel Tata wants the meeting recordings

The September 17 board meeting is central to the dispute because the directors approved Chandrasekaran’s reappointment for another five-year term. Noel opposed the decision and has questioned the way the matter was brought before the board, the voting process and the subsequent documentation.

Noel has argued that the original and revised agendas did not clearly identify Chandrasekaran’s reappointment as a proposed resolution. He has also questioned whether the board’s discussion under an update on the NRC’s deliberations was sufficient to take a formal decision on the matter.

The September 3 NRC meeting is also important. According to reports, the committee discussed Chandrasekaran’s earlier decision not to make himself available for reappointment and decided to ask him to reconsider. Noel has sought the recording and related documentation to establish what was discussed and how the committee reached its position.

For Noel, the recordings could provide an independent account of the discussions, particularly where there are differences over the agenda, deliberations and minutes. He has also raised questions about the status of the NRC minutes circulated to him, reportedly pointing out that the version he received was a draft without the signatures of committee members.

Tata Sons had earlier rejected the request

Tata Sons had responded to Noel’s earlier communications by declining to provide the recording of the September 17 meeting. In a letter dated November 9, the company said there was no established practice of sharing audio or video recordings of physical board meetings with directors.

The company maintained that recording board proceedings is required when one or more directors participate virtually, but that the law and the company’s Articles of Association do not require recordings of in-person meetings to be retained or shared with directors.

According to Tata Sons, recordings of physical meetings are used to assist the company secretary in preparing draft minutes. The company also said that the draft minutes of the September 17 meeting had been uploaded to its board application on October 1. It received Noel’s comments on October 8 and said appropriate changes had been incorporated.

Tata Sons further stated that the reappointment was discussed under the agenda item relating to the NRC’s deliberations and that all directors participated in the discussion. The resolution was carried by a majority.

The company has also defended the subsequent filing of the resolution, stating that it acted in accordance with its statutory obligations under the Companies Act, 2013.

Why Noel has questioned Venu Srinivasan’s vote

A major part of Noel’s latest objection concerns Srinivasan, chairman emeritus of TVS Motor Company and a Tata Sons director nominated by Tata Trusts.

Noel has argued that Srinivasan should not have participated in the NRC deliberations or the board decision on Chandrasekaran’s reappointment because of business dealings involving TVS Motor and Hanno One Warehousing, a company associated with members of Chandrasekaran’s family.

The reported arrangements between TVS Motor and Hanno One are at the centre of the disclosure dispute. Hanno One has been linked to Chandrasekaran’s wife and son. Media reports have referred to a long-term land lease near TVS Motor’s Hosur facility and plans involving industrial infrastructure, as well as a proposed industrial park near the company’s Mysuru factory.

Noel’s concern is that these relationships should have been adequately disclosed and examined before Srinivasan took part in decisions concerning Chandrasekaran’s continuation as chairman. He has questioned whether Srinivasan’s position as a director and his association with TVS Motor created a conflict requiring him to withdraw from the deliberations.

Tata Sons has rejected that interpretation. The company has said that Hanno One’s incorporation and interests were disclosed in April 2025 to companies where Chandrasekaran serves as chairman. It has also maintained that there have been no transactions between Tata Sons and TVS Motor or between Tata Sons and Hanno One.

The company’s position is that a contract awarded by TVS Motor to another company in which Chandrasekaran’s family has a disclosed interest does not create a conflict with Tata Sons. It has also said Srinivasan’s relationship with TVS Motor was disclosed and that his vote did not violate the company’s code of conduct.

Disagreement over the reappointment process

The dispute extends beyond the recordings and the question of Srinivasan’s participation. Noel has also challenged the procedure through which Chandrasekaran’s reappointment was approved and the subsequent filing of the resolution.

He has questioned whether the reappointment should have been handled through a selection committee under Article 118 of Tata Sons’ Articles of Association. Tata Sons, however, has maintained that the provision does not apply to the reappointment of an incumbent chairman.

Noel has also raised questions about the timing of the resolution and its filing with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. Tata Sons has defended the filing, saying the certified resolution was issued under the board’s authority and submitted in accordance with the applicable legal requirements.

The two sides have also differed over the legal opinions obtained in connection with the decision. Tata Sons has said it obtained legal advice before the board meeting and that subsequent opinions supported the earlier advice. Noel has questioned aspects of the process and sought information about the instructions and disclosures provided to the legal advisers.

The disagreement has brought the interpretation of the company’s Articles of Association, directors’ duties and the rights of Tata Trusts’ nominee directors into focus.

November 26 board meeting could be significant

The next Tata Sons board meeting is scheduled for November 26. The final minutes of the September 17 meeting are expected to come up for approval, making the meeting an important point in the continuing disagreement.

The minutes matter because they provide the formal record of the board’s deliberations and decisions. Directors can raise objections or seek changes before the record is finalised. Noel’s questions over the agenda, the discussion and the voting process could therefore remain part of the board’s consideration.

The latest letter also comes amid wider differences within Tata Trusts, whose shareholding gives it a central role in the governance of Tata Sons. Noel’s position as Tata Trusts chairman and as a Tata Sons director places him at the centre of the debate over the relationship between the charitable trusts and the group’s holding company.

The immediate issues are whether the requested recordings will be preserved or made available, how the board addresses Noel’s objections and whether the minutes accurately reflect the September proceedings. Neither the renewed request nor the allegations of conflict establish that the reappointment was invalid or that any director breached their duties.

For now, Tata Sons continues to defend its earlier decisions, while Noel is pressing for greater access to records and further scrutiny of the process. The November 26 meeting could provide the next indication of how the board intends to handle the growing governance dispute.