Houston: As Portugal gear up for the FIFA World Cup 2026, one question continues to dominate discussions among fans and pundits alike: will Cristiano Ronaldo be their greatest asset—or a potential liability?

Once the undisputed talisman of Portuguese football, Ronaldo now finds himself at the center of a debate shaped by age, form, and the evolution of the national team.

A changing narrative

At the start of the 2022 World Cup, it would have been unthinkable to question Ronaldo’s place in the Portugal lineup. But that tournament marked a turning point.

After scoring just once—via a penalty—in the group stage, Ronaldo reacted angrily to being substituted against South Korea. The fallout saw him dropped to the bench for the knockout clash against Switzerland, signaling a shift in the team dynamic.

The concerns deepened at Euro 2024, where Ronaldo failed to score in a major international tournament for the first time in his career.

Fans split on his role

Among supporters, opinions are sharply divided.

Some believe Portugal’s system functions more fluidly without Ronaldo leading the line, arguing that younger players better fit the team’s modern, high-pressing style.

Others worry that Ronaldo’s towering presence and global stature could make it difficult for the team to move out of his shadow, particularly if he struggles to accept a reduced role.

Evidence of enduring quality

Despite the criticism, there are clear signs that Ronaldo still has plenty to offer.

During Portugal’s victorious 2025 UEFA Nations League campaign, he scored eight goals, including a crucial equalizer in the final against Spain. At club level, he also enjoyed a prolific season with Al-Nassr, finishing as their top scorer with 28 goals en route to a league title.

These performances underline his enduring ability to deliver in key moments.

Leadership and experience

Beyond goals, Ronaldo’s experience is invaluable—especially in high-pressure situations.

For a squad that includes several emerging talents, his presence can provide composure and guidance. His mentality, honed over two decades at the highest level, is something few players can replicate.

As one fan put it, Ronaldo is “the player you want on the pitch when everything is on the line.”

The age factor

At 41, Ronaldo will be the oldest outfield player at the tournament and is set to appear in a record-extending sixth World Cup.

While questions about his physical decline are inevitable, comparisons with players like Lionel Messi and Luka Modric—who continue to perform at elite levels in their mid-to-late 30s—offer a counterpoint.

Teammates, too, remain in awe of his fitness and discipline, with midfielder Vitinha describing his physique as “incredible.”

Tactical dilemma for Portugal

The challenge for Portugal lies in balancing Ronaldo’s strengths with the team’s broader tactical needs.

Should he remain the focal point of the attack, or transition into a more selective role—perhaps as an impact substitute or situational starter?

Manager Roberto Martinez faces a delicate task: maximizing Ronaldo’s contributions without disrupting the team’s rhythm.

The emotional connection

Beyond tactics and statistics, Ronaldo’s influence extends into the emotional fabric of the team and its supporters.

For younger fans especially, he remains a hero and symbol of Portuguese football. His presence alone can inspire belief—a factor that cannot be easily quantified.

Verdict: Asset or liability?

The answer likely lies somewhere in between.

Cristiano Ronaldo is no longer the unstoppable force he once was, but writing him off entirely would be premature. His goal-scoring instincts, leadership, and experience still make him a valuable asset.

However, Portugal’s success may depend on how effectively they adapt his role to suit the team’s evolving identity.

Conclusion

As Portugal begin their World Cup campaign, the Ronaldo question will remain under intense scrutiny.

Whether he emerges as the difference-maker or a contentious figure could ultimately shape Portugal’s journey in what may be his final appearance on football’s biggest stage.