A California jury has ordered Starbucks to pay a staggering $50 million to Michael Garcia, a delivery driver who suffered third-degree burns and nerve damage after a venti-sized hot tea spilled on him due to a loosely secured lid.

The incident occurred in February 2020 at a Los Angeles drive-through when Garcia was handed three hot teas. One cup’s lid wasn’t properly fastened, causing the scalding beverage to spill onto his lap, severely burning his penis, groin, and thighs. Garcia endured multiple skin grafts, ongoing pain, disfigurement, and debilitating psychological trauma.

The jury’s verdict, as cited by CNN and Courtroom View Network, awarded damages covering physical suffering, mental anguish, loss of enjoyment, disfigurement, anxiety, and emotional distress. Garcia’s lawyer emphasized the lasting impact on his client’s life and well-being.

Starbucks, however, pushed back, expressing sympathy but disagreeing with the jury’s decision, calling the payout “excessive” and defending their safety protocols. They later reportedly offered $30 million in settlement, under the condition of confidentiality, but Garcia demanded a formal apology and concrete safety reforms—requests Starbucks allegedly declined.

This landmark case highlights the serious risks posed by negligence in product handling and the heavy financial toll corporations may face when found responsible.